A single contract simplifies the client’s dealings. Separate contracts give the client more visibility of the work and the prices. Yet these advantages are not enough to decide: the contract structure must match the maturity of the brief, the team available and the risks the project can bear.
The comparison becomes useful when the options are examined on a like-for-like scope: same performance, same input studies, same dates and same scope boundaries. An apparently cheaper bid may leave the client with interfaces, studies or works that are included in another. This choice is prepared during project structuring, before tendering. This guide covers private-sector contracts under French law.
Separate trade packages, main contractor, consortium, general contractor: what are the differences?
Four contract structures exist for private-sector work in France. With separate trade packages, the client signs one contract per trade. A consortium brings several contractors together in one contract. A main contractor carries out all trades on a design produced by others. A general contractor adds the design and delivers the building under a single contract.
- Separate trade packages (lots séparés or corps d’état séparés). The client enters into several contracts and has direct access to each contractor. The client must organise the technical, contractual and time coordination of the whole: that is the role of construction supervision (MOEX, maîtrise d’œuvre d’exécution) and of scheduling and coordination (OPC, ordonnancement, pilotage et coordination).
- Temporary consortium of contractors (groupement momentané d’entreprises). Several contractors sign the same contract, represented by a lead member (mandataire). In a joint consortium (groupement conjoint), each is liable only for its own share; in a joint and several consortium (groupement solidaire), each is liable for the whole. Under French law, joint and several liability is not presumed (Article 1310 of the Civil Code): it must be written into the contract.
- Main contractor (entreprise générale). A single contractor takes on all the works, all trades, usually on the basis of a design produced separately by an architect and engineering consultants. It carries out part of the works itself and subcontracts the rest.
- General contractor (contractant général). It usually combines design, engineering and construction in a single offer, at an agreed price and timescale, and entrusts the works to contractors of its choosing.
The exact scope comes from the contract: none of these labels, on its own, defines a uniform regime or guarantee. For builders’ liability under French law, it is the contract for works (contrat de louage d’ouvrage) entered into with the client that makes a firm a “builder”, whatever its title (Article 1792-1 of the Civil Code). Intermediate solutions exist, such as macro-packages, or a single contract for construction after a design phase kept by the client.
For private-sector contracts, the choice is free. For public contracts in France, the rule is the reverse: contracts are awarded in separate packages, unless their subject matter does not allow separate services to be identified (Article L2113-10 of the Public Procurement Code).
In short: the difference lies in the number of contracts the client signs and where the design sits. Several contracts and coordination to organise with separate trade packages; one contract for the works with a main contractor or a consortium; one contract for design and works with a general contractor.
Is a general contractor a house builder or a developer?
No. A general contractor works under a freely negotiated contract for works (contrat d’entreprise). Under French law, the individual house-building contract (CCMI, contrat de construction de maison individuelle) and the property development contract (contrat de promotion immobilière) are two regimes defined by statute, each with its own guarantees. Confusing them skews the comparison of bids.
- The CCMI is mandatory for anyone who undertakes to build, from a plan they have proposed, a residential building with no more than two homes for the same client (Article L231-1 of the Construction and Housing Code). A general contractor that falls within this case must enter into a CCMI, whatever the contract is called.
- The property development contract is a mandate: the developer undertakes to have a construction project carried out for an agreed price, by means of contracts for works, and guarantees performance of the obligations of the contractors it has dealt with in the client’s name (Article 1831-1 of the Civil Code). Depending on the commitments made and the authority to represent the client, whether a contract falls into this category may need to be examined.
In short: “general contractor” is industry usage, not a legal category. Before comparing, have the proposed contract classified: contract for works, CCMI or property development contract. The guarantees owed to the client are not the same.
What are the advantages and trade-offs of each structure?
A single contract groups the interfaces together and gives an overall price, but concentrates the risk on one contractor and makes the price harder to read. Separate trade packages give a price per trade and direct access to contractors, but leave coordination and interfaces to the client and its design team.
Scroll the table sideways →
| Criterion | Separate trade packages | Consortium of contractors | Main contractor | General contractor |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Works contracts signed by the client | One per package | One, signed by all the contractors | One | One, design included |
| Design | Client’s design team | Client’s design team | Client’s design team | Included in the contract |
| Interfaces between trades | Coordination to be organised across the contracts (MOEX, OPC) | Handled by the lead member, within the limits of its mandate | Grouped with the contractor | Grouped with the contractor |
| Price transparency | Breakdown by package, coordination costs to be added | Breakdown by consortium member | Overall price; detail depends on what the contract requires | Depends on the brief, the exclusions and the detail provided |
| Changes | Effects to be dealt with for each package concerned | Negotiated by the lead member | Negotiated with the contractor | Negotiated with the contractor, design included |
| Contractor failure | Impact often localised, takeover interfaces to manage | Covered by the other members if the consortium is joint and several | Risk concentrated on one party | Risk concentrated on one party, design included |
| Client resources needed | Stronger decision-making and coordination capacity | Checking the mandate and joint and several liability | Checking commitments and payments | Checking the brief, commitments and trade-off decisions |
The number of contractual counterparties does not reflect the real number of technical dependencies. A single contractor still has to coordinate its design work, suppliers and subcontractors; under French law, it must have each subcontractor accepted, and its payment terms approved, by the client (Article 3 of Law No. 75-1334 of 31 December 1975). The client still has to watch the items left outside the contractor’s scope, notably the operator’s equipment or work by third parties.
Whatever the structure, two protections are checked at signature. Under French law, each builder must provide evidence of ten-year latent defects liability insurance (décennale) when work starts on site (Article L241-1 of the Insurance Code). The contract may provide for a retention of no more than 5% on each interim payment, which can be replaced by a guarantee (caution) (Article 1 of Law No. 71-584 of 16 July 1971).
In short: a single contract moves coordination to the contractor; it does not remove it. Separate trade packages make the price readable package by package, provided the cost of coordination is added. In both cases, subcontractors, insurance and retention are checked at signature.
Is the brief stable enough for a single overall price?
An overall price is only worth something if the brief is fixed: uses, floor areas, performance, operating constraints, limits of supply. As long as these points are moving, a single contract rests on exclusions and assumptions that every change calls into question. Separate trade packages cope better with a brief that firms up in stages.
Assumptions about the ground, the existing building or the permits need particular attention. While the brief is still changing, early visibility does not guarantee the final cost. The change procedure, and how its consequences will be priced, must be set out before signing. Under French law, for a building constructed for a lump sum (à forfait) to an agreed plan, the contractor cannot claim a price increase for changes that were not authorised in writing and whose price was not agreed with the client (Article 1793 of the Civil Code).
Separate trade packages give more direct control over successive tenders and technical choices. This flexibility has a cost: late decisions can affect several contracts and shift responsibilities. An organised design team and active management of the schedule are needed to keep the whole consistent.
Which risks does the price include?
No structure is inherently cheaper. The price of a single overall contract includes coordination, part of the contingencies and the contractor’s margin; with separate trade packages these stay with the client, who pays separately for construction supervision (MOEX) and the OPC. Only the full cost, on a like-for-like scope, can be compared.
The financial analysis brings together the works, studies, fees, insurance and any services left to the client. It distinguishes firm prices, provisional sums, options and assumptions still open. Claimed savings are only comparable if the expected outcome is too.
A single overall contract can include taking on certain organisational or construction risks. Whether they are really transferred, however, depends on the clauses and on the contractor’s ability to honour its commitments. Solvency, insurance and guarantees therefore matter as much as the headline price.
There is no universal percentage showing that one structure always costs less than the other. The method is to rebuild the full cost of the project and identify the contingencies still borne by each party. Our guide Scheduling and coordination (OPC): how to assess its cost and value describes the cost item that separate trade packages add.
The clauses matter as much as the structure. For private contracts in France, standard NF P 03-001, the general administrative conditions for private building works contracts, applies only if the contract refers to it. It was written for works contracts: a general contractor’s contract, which includes design, must itself deal with what the standard does not cover.
In short: compare full costs. To the price of the single overall contract, add what it excludes; to the total of the separate packages, add construction supervision, the OPC and a provision for interfaces. Then check who bears each contingency, and whether that party has the means to do so.
What happens if a contractor fails?
With separate trade packages, a contractor’s failure stops one package and disrupts those that depend on it. With a general contractor or a main contractor, the failure of that contractor stops the whole site and can leave subcontractors unpaid. In both cases, recovery depends on what the client holds: up-to-date drawings, studies, the list of parties involved, guarantees.
Before choosing, the client can test this scenario. Does it have the latest drawings, the studies, the list of parties involved and the status of orders? Do its rights to use the documents allow the project to continue? Can the guarantees be called on under realistic conditions?
With a single overall contract, handover, continuity or substitution clauses must be examined without assuming they will always allow an immediate restart, particularly where insolvency proceedings are under way. Under French law, in safeguard proceedings (sauvegarde) as in judicial liquidation, opening the proceedings does not in itself terminate the contract in progress, but only the administrator or the liquidator can require it to continue (Articles L622-13 and L641-11-1 of the Commercial Code). The steps to take are set out in our guide Contractor in liquidation: how to regain control of the site.
With separate trade packages, replacing a contractor still leaves open questions of substrates, builder’s work openings and liability at the interfaces. An apparently self-contained package can hold up several other contractors. How the work will be taken over must therefore be planned for in both structures.
What control should the client keep?
Whatever the structure, the client keeps four controls: compliance with the brief, payment applications, changes and schedule milestones. With a general contractor, the client exercises them alone or with owner’s representation (AMO, assistance à maîtrise d’ouvrage). With separate trade packages, the MOEX and OPC consultants exercise them on the client’s behalf, each within its own appointment.
Using a general contractor therefore does not remove the need for checks. Independent owner’s representation can be useful, with a scope that respects the contractual organisation and avoids directly instructing the contractor’s subcontractors. However, under French law, a client who becomes aware of a subcontractor on site that has not been accepted must give the main contractor or the subcontractor formal notice to regularise the position, unless the client is an individual building a home for themselves or their family (Article 14-1 of the same Law of 31 December 1975).
With separate trade packages, the client needs a responsive decision-making process and precise coordination. The choice of teams and the quality of the tender documents become part of the structure itself, not mere ancillary services. The split of roles is described in MOEX, OPC, AMO: who does what on your project?; the framework for wider delegation in Outsourcing client-side project management.
In short: signing a single contract does not remove the need to check. The brief, payments, changes and schedule must still be verified by the client or its representative. With separate trade packages, this control is entrusted to the MOEX and OPC consultants, whose appointments must be written with no overlap.
General contractor or separate trade packages: your questions
Are a general contractor and a main contractor the same thing?
No. A main contractor carries out all the works on a design produced by the client’s architect and engineering consultants. A general contractor also takes on the design and delivers the building under a single contract. Offers sometimes overlap: compare the services and the written commitments, not the title.
Does a single overall contract guarantee the final price?
Only within the limits of what it describes. The agreed price covers the brief, less the exclusions and assumptions written into the contract. A change requested after signature is negotiated separately. Under French law, with a lump-sum contract, the contractor can only claim extra for changes authorised in writing at an agreed price (Article 1793 of the Civil Code).
Are separate trade packages suitable for a small project?
Floor area alone does not decide it. The number of interfaces, technical complexity, operating constraints and the client’s availability determine its ability to manage this structure. A small refurbishment on an occupied site may need more coordination than a larger new building.
What is a joint, or a joint and several, consortium?
Several contractors sign the same contract together, represented by a lead member. In a joint consortium, each contractor is committed only to its share of the works. In a joint and several consortium, each can be called on for the whole. As joint and several liability is not presumed under French law, it must be stated expressly in the contract, including that of the lead member.
Do you still need a lead consultant with a general contractor?
The general contractor handles the design and management of the works on its own account. The client therefore has no lead consultant on its side, unless it appoints one for the brief or for checking. That is the role an owner’s representative independent of the contractor can play.
Can several arrangements be combined?
Yes. Macro-packages, for example the weathertight shell on one side and building services trades on the other, or a separate design phase followed by a single overall contract, can work. Scope boundaries and responsibilities must remain explicit between the groupings; otherwise the interfaces belong to nobody.
How do you compare structures for your brief?
The comparison is made on your brief, not in general: identical scope, full cost of each structure, list of retained risks and the means of control needed. It is carried out before tendering, while the choice is still open, based on the brief, the studies available and the date the building must be in operation.
PRIMOE carries out this analysis in Paris and Île-de-France as part of project structuring and the early-stage study in our development services: organisational options, interfaces to keep, services needed for monitoring. To discuss your project: contact@primoe.fr.




