primoe.
FRLet’s talk about your project

Site audit: how to get a diagnosis you can act on

Check progress, understand the variances and get a report that prepares the decision to carry on or to recover the site.

Read the guide 11 min read

By Alain Bonnetaud, founder of PRIMOE · Updated · published

The schedule shows one level of progress, the interim valuations show another, and site visits reveal unresolved issues. When a client can no longer reconcile this information, a site audit rebuilds a common baseline. It must explain the variances and the decisions they call for.

The assignment can take place before a site recovery, when the team changes or at the first sign of a persistent drift. Its value rests on a well-framed question, identified documents and a method that separates what has been observed from what still needs checking.

The technical and financial audit is the second step of our stalled site recovery method. It is just as useful on a site that is still running but whose figures no longer add up.

When should you commission a site audit?

Commission a site audit when several warning signs build up: milestones pushed back from one meeting to the next, interim valuations that no longer match what you see on site, missing construction documents, decisions left open. An audit is also essential before restarting a stalled site or changing the team.

  • Milestones regularly pushed back, with no identified cause.
  • Invoicing that is hard to reconcile with the work done.
  • Missing construction documents or drawing approvals.
  • Decisions left open from one meeting to the next.
  • Teams that change often, subcontractors chasing payment.
  • A site stoppage, or a contractor’s failure.

A one-off delay does not necessarily justify a full assignment. Several converging signs, on the other hand, should prompt a closer look: milestones regularly pushed back, invoicing that is hard to explain, missing construction documents or decisions left open from one meeting to the next.

Frequent changes of team, payment applications out of step with the work done or repeated claims from subcontractors also call for a check. These signs do not, on their own, prove fault or financial failure. They help target the checks.

The terms of reference state the expected result: establish the remaining work, assess how reliable a date is, reconcile invoicing with progress, or prepare a tender for the recovery. Being this precise makes it possible to choose the right skills and avoid a general report that is of little use.

In short: a site audit is triggered by a cluster of warning signs, not by a single delay, and always before a site recovery. The terms of reference must state what the client wants to know: the remaining work, how reliable a date is, the gap between what has been invoiced and what has been built, or the information needed for a recovery tender.

Site audit, out-of-court expert assessment, court-ordered expert assessment: what is the difference?

A site audit is commissioned by the client alone, to make decisions. A joint out-of-court expert assessment (expertise amiable contradictoire) involves the other parties, who submit their observations. A court-ordered expert assessment (expertise judiciaire) is ordered by a judge, who sets its terms. All three can serve as evidence, but none of them decides liability: under French law, only the judge does that.

Scroll the table horizontally →

AssignmentWho decides on itDo the other parties take part?What it is for
Site auditThe clientOnly if the client invites themEstablishing the facts and preparing the client’s decisions
Joint out-of-court expert assessmentThe parties, or one of them convening the othersYes, they submit their observationsSeeking agreement on the findings, negotiating
Court-ordered expert assessmentThe judgeYes, under the judge’s supervisionInforming the judge on a question of fact

A private audit is an observation and analysis assignment given by the party commissioning it. It may focus on technical matters, the schedule, the accounts or the documents. A joint out-of-court expert assessment also organises the participation and observations of the parties concerned.

Under French law, a court-ordered expert assessment is ordered by a judge, who defines its terms (Article 265 of the Code of Civil Procedure). Before any trial, a measure of inquiry can be requested, by ex parte application or in summary proceedings (référé), where there is a legitimate reason to preserve or establish evidence. When the measure concerns a building, only the court for the place where the building is located has jurisdiction (Article 145 of the Code of Civil Procedure).

The court-appointed expert sheds technical light on questions of fact, within the terms of the assignment (Article 232 of the Code of Civil Procedure); the judge decides the dispute and is not bound by the expert’s conclusions (Article 246 of the Code of Civil Procedure). A private audit should therefore not be presented as a ruling on liability. It can nevertheless support a negotiation or contribute to a body of evidence, provided its method and its limits are made explicit.

The Cour de cassation, France’s highest court in civil matters, has set out what such a report is worth: the judge cannot refuse to examine a report properly filed in the proceedings and open to discussion by the parties, but cannot rely solely on a non-judicial expert report produced at the request of one of them (Cour de cassation, 28 September 2012, No. 11-18.710). An audit therefore carries more weight when other evidence confirms it: formal records, site minutes, interim valuations, correspondence.

In short: a site audit is for making decisions, an out-of-court expert assessment for establishing the findings together, a court-ordered one for informing a judge. An audit commissioned by one party can be produced in court, but the judge cannot rely on it alone. Hence the value of dated documents that corroborate it.

What documents should you gather before the audit visit?

Before the visit, gather the contracts and their amendments, the drawings sorted by revision, the successive schedules, the site minutes, the interim valuations, the invoices and payments, the reports of the technical inspector and the important correspondence. Whatever is missing is listed: it is a limit of the audit, to be stated in the report.

  • Brief, works contracts, amendments and pending quotes.
  • Contracts of the lead consultant and the other consultants.
  • Drawings and construction documents, by revision, with their approval status.
  • Schedules in their successive versions.
  • Site minutes.
  • Interim valuations, payment certificates, invoices and payments.
  • Inspection reports, test results, formal records.
  • Formal notices (mises en demeure) and significant correspondence.

The visit is more effective when the auditor knows the brief, the contracts and the latest changes to the project. Drawings should be sorted by revision, amendments kept apart from mere quotes, and schedules kept in their successive versions.

The file also includes the site minutes, interim valuations, invoices, payments, inspections, tests and significant correspondence. Missing documents go on a dedicated list. Their absence is a limit of the analysis, not an invitation to fill the gaps in the story with assumptions.

For areas that are about to be covered up or altered, preserving the evidence is arranged before the work goes ahead. Depending on what is at stake, notices to attend, formal records or further investigations may be needed. The auditor describes the means used and the parts of the works that remained inaccessible.

What does a site audit check?

The audit cross-checks five readings of the same site: the schedule, physical progress, finances, decisions and the parties involved. None is enough on its own. It is the gap between two readings, for example between observed progress and the amount invoiced, that reveals the problem and points to the decision to be taken.

Scroll the table horizontally →

ReadingCheck to carry outQuestion for the client
ScheduleCompare forecast, actual and dependenciesWhich prerequisites now drive the completion date?
ProgressMeasure by area and by item of workWhat can be kept and what remains to be done?
FinancesReconcile work done, invoiced, paid and committedWhere are the variances and the future needs?
DecisionsReconstruct requests, replies and who had authorityWhich pending decisions are blocking progress?
PartiesIdentify contract holders, subcontractors and interfacesWho must produce, correct or pass on each item?

The readings have to converge. High physical progress can hide tests that have not been carried out or missing documents essential for operating the building. Likewise, a correctly calculated interim valuation can rest on an unchecked quantity. The audit explains these gaps instead of adding up unrelated indicators. Reconciling work done with work invoiced follows the method described in our guide on checking interim valuations and the payment certificate.

What should a site audit report contain?

A site audit report sets out the scope of the assignment, the list of documents examined and documents missing, dated and located findings, an analysis of the variances and recommendations ranked by urgency. It separates what has been observed, what is assumed and what remains to be checked.

  1. The scope of the assignment and the question asked.
  2. The documents examined, the people met, the missing documents.
  3. The findings, dated, located and illustrated.
  4. The analysis of the variances: progress, finances, schedule, documents.
  5. The recommendations: urgent measures, investigations to commission, decisions on carrying on.
  6. The appendices, which let you trace the source of each conclusion.

The report describes the scope of the assignment, the documents examined, the people met and the findings. It separates facts, assumptions and analyses that need further work. The appendices make it possible to find the photo, drawing or invoice behind a conclusion.

The recommendations distinguish urgent measures, investigations to commission and decisions on carrying on. Each proposed action has a purpose, a person responsible to be appointed, a prerequisite and an estimated impact. Amounts or timescales that are still uncertain remain flagged as such.

The author’s expertise must match the conclusions drawn. A progress audit is not a full structural check. When a repair solution requires design, calculations or specific insurance, that assignment must be explicitly given to the appropriate professional.

In short: a useful audit report says what was looked at, what was found, what is missing and what has to be decided. Each conclusion refers back to a document or a photo. Uncertain amounts and timescales are flagged as such, and each recommendation has a purpose, an owner and a prerequisite.

What should you do once the audit report is delivered?

Once the report is delivered, the client holds a review meeting, chooses the actions and turns them into three documents: a reset schedule, a cost-to-complete budget and a contractual strategy towards the contractors. Without that step, the report remains a snapshot of the problem.

The review meeting allows the client to choose the actions and ask for any further work needed. The priority variances then feed into the schedule, the cost-to-complete budget and the contractual strategy. Without this practical follow-through, the report risks remaining a snapshot of the problem.

The follow-up keeps the initial assumptions and the evidence that confirmed or changed them. This makes it possible to tell a real improvement from a mere shift in the baseline date or scope. Reviews are held at a pace suited to the decisions still open.

If the site has stalled, the audit opens the next stages of the recovery: status of the contracts, tendering, restart schedule. These steps are described in our guides stalled site: building a recovery plan and contractor in liquidation: regaining control of the site.

How should you scope a site audit?

Scope the assignment in four points: the question the report must answer, the scope (trade packages, areas, period), the documents you can provide, and the decision you will then have to take. The latest site minutes, the schedule, the contracts and the interim valuations are enough to define the checks to plan on site.

We scope the audit from the problem you face and the decisions you need to take. It can remain a one-off assignment or lead on to a site recovery, then to construction supervision (MOEX) through to practical completion. We work in Paris and Île-de-France: see our Delivery path: owner’s representation (AMO), MOEX, scheduling and coordination (OPC) and site recovery or write to us.

Disputes, contractors, price, repairs: common questions about site audits

Can a private site audit be used in a dispute?

Yes, as evidence. Under French law, the judge must examine a report properly produced and discussed by the parties, but cannot base the decision solely on an expert report carried out at the request of a single party. The audit therefore carries weight if it is precise, dated and confirmed by other documents. It does not guarantee the outcome of litigation.

Should the contractors be invited to the audit visit?

It is not compulsory for an audit commissioned by the client alone. When a contractor’s work or accounts are being examined, inviting it and recording its observations strengthens the file and prepares the ground for discussion. The decision is taken before the visit, depending on what is at stake as evidence and on the state of relations with the contractor.

How much does a site audit cost?

There is no benchmark fee. The price depends on the scope, the specialisms required, the state of the available documents and the investigations to be carried out on site. A fact-finding visit, a full audit before a site recovery and a court-ordered expert assessment are not comparable services. Ask for a quote based on the question asked and the deliverables expected.

Can the auditor direct the repairs?

Not as part of the audit. Directing works requires a separate assignment, expressly given, with the corresponding skills and insurance. The audit report confers no authority to direct the site. If the client wants the same professional to carry on, it then appoints them for construction supervision (MOEX).

Who can carry out a site audit?

A professional independent of the contractors being audited, whose expertise matches the question asked: construction supervision (MOEX) for progress, documents and accounts, an engineering consultancy for structure or building services, a cost consultant for pricing the remaining work. An audit that covers several subjects brings these skills together in a single report.

Is an audit useful if the site has not stopped?

Yes. In fact, that is when it leaves the most options open. On a site that is still running, the audit measures the gap between the announced schedule and actual progress, and between what has been invoiced and what has been built, and identifies the decisions that are holding things up. The client can then fix the organisation before the drift turns into a stoppage.

Do you need a judicial officer’s report as well as the audit?

The two complement each other. The report, drawn up by a judicial officer (commissaire de justice), records the condition of the site on a given date; the audit analyses that condition and draws conclusions from it. Before covering up work, bringing in a new contractor or terminating a contract, having the existing works formally recorded protects the evidence the audit will rely on.

Alain BonnetaudFounder of PRIMOE

Contact

Let’s talk about your project.

A building to study, a construction site to run or restart, an operator to find: tell us where you stand.

3 rue Alfred Roll, 75017 Paris, France · Projects across Paris and Île-de-France