A building handed over after the planned date does not, on its own, mean that every day of delay can be attributed to one contractor. Design studies, the client’s choices, supplies and the work of other trade packages may all have affected the same deadline. The decision must rest on a chronology and on the obligations actually agreed.
On a private contract, delay penalties flow from the contract. Applying them means checking the clause, the binding deadline, the extensions and the formalities. A good file is built during the works, with information kept as events occur.
Where do the rate and the cap of delay penalties come from?
Under French law, on a private works contract, no statute sets the rate or the cap of delay penalties. They come from the contract clause, most often in the CCAP (the contract’s special administrative conditions, cahier des clauses administratives particulières), or from the NF P 03-001 standard where the contract refers to it. Only the contract for building a single-family house (contrat de construction de maison individuelle) has a regulatory minimum.
Scroll the table horizontally →
| Situation | Rate | Cap | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Private contract with its own clause | The rate in the clause | The cap in the clause, if there is one | The CCAP or the contract |
| Private contract that refers to the NF P 03-001 standard | 1/3,000 of the contract value per day, unless otherwise stipulated | 5% of the contract value | Article 9.5 of the standard, October 2017 edition, according to the Fédération française du bâtiment (French building federation) |
| Contract for building a single-family house | At least 1/3,000 of the agreed price per day of delay | Not set by this text | Article R231-14 of the Construction and Housing Code |
| Private contract with no penalty clause | No penalty | Not applicable | Damages under ordinary contract law, to be proved |
The NF P 03-001 standard is a set of general conditions applied on a voluntary basis: it binds the parties only if the contract refers to it, and the CCAP may depart from it. Some web pages quote a rate of 1/1,000: check which edition of the standard your contract refers to and read Article 9.5 itself. The rules for single-family house building contracts (Article L231-2 of the Construction and Housing Code) do not extend to other private contracts.
In short: the rate and the cap of delay penalties are found in your contract, not in the law. The 1/3,000 per day and the 5% cap are those of the NF P 03-001 standard, and apply only if the contract refers to it and does not depart from it.
Which date should the delay be measured against?
The delay is measured against the deadline that the contract makes binding on the contractor: the one in the contract and its appended schedule, as changed by amendments and by the extensions granted. It is for the client claiming penalties to prove that deadline. A schedule circulated for information is not always enough.
Under French law, a party claiming performance of an obligation must prove it (Article 1353 of the Civil Code). The first task is therefore to identify the deadline concerned: completion of a trade package, handover of an area, practical completion or another milestone defined in the contract. These dates are not always equivalent and may be subject to different conditions.
The file brings together the contract, the appended schedule, the site instructions (ordres de service, OS), the notices, the amendments and the decisions that changed the deadline. It states how days are counted, calendar or working days, any caps and the conditions that trigger the penalty. A recent version of the schedule does not, on its own, change the contractual commitments.
A coordination schedule remains useful even when it does not carry the same weight as the contract schedule. It sheds light on the organisation and the operational commitments. But not every deviation from that document should be turned into a right to a sanction.
What should be recorded during the works?
Record dated facts as they happen: the document or decision awaited, the planned date, the actual date, the task held up and the person who was supposed to act. The site minutes circulated after each meeting are the main document in the file; written after the event, they lose most of their force.
“The package is falling behind” tells you little. A note stating the document awaited, its planned date, its actual date and the task held up makes it possible to reconstruct what happened.
Scroll the table horizontally →
| Information | What it lets you check |
|---|---|
| Date the event became known | When a warning or a response became possible |
| Task or area concerned | Link with the work actually prevented |
| Response expected and person responsible | Commitment requested and decision-making authority |
| Planned and actual dates | Length of the wait or the slippage |
| Related documents | Drawings, letters, deliveries, surveys or photographs |
| Action to reduce the impact | Measures proposed, accepted and carried out |
Successive versions of the schedules are kept with their assumptions. Workforce or delivery data are only of value if they are tied to an activity and a period. A pile of unindexed documents makes the analysis slower and easier to challenge.
This tracking is part of the scheduling and coordination (OPC) service (ordonnancement, pilotage et coordination), which keeps a record of contractual dates, observed delays and their causes. On our sites, every meeting is followed by written site minutes.
In short: proof of a delay is built during the works, not at practical completion. Dated site minutes that name the task held up, the document awaited and the person responsible for it are worth more than a file pieced together months later from everyone’s memories.
What really pushed back the schedule?
Only a delay on the critical path, that is, the chain of tasks that drives the deadline, pushes back the end of the works. The analysis therefore isolates those tasks, then attributes each period of slippage to its cause: contractor, design, client decision, another trade package or an external event.
A late task does not always push back the end of the works. It may have float, or run in parallel with another sequence. Conversely, an apparently minor decision can delay a purchase on which testing and commissioning depend. The OPC consultant compares forecasts with actual progress; the lead consultant sets out the technical and contractual constraints. The reasoning must remain explainable from the documents.
Concurrent causes call for particular scrutiny. If a late drawing and a lack of access prevent the same work over the same period, adding their durations together gives a misleading count. Liability cannot be pinned solely on whoever finished last. On late drawings, see our guide on construction drawing approval.
Bad weather, variations and other events relied on are examined in the light of the contract and of their actual effects. A difficulty on site is not automatically force majeure: under French law, Article 1218 of the Civil Code covers an event beyond the control of the party bound by the obligation, which could not reasonably have been foreseen when the contract was made and whose effects cannot be avoided by appropriate measures. An extension of time must be examined and decided by the person with authority under the applicable framework.
How do you apply the penalties set in the contract?
Applying delay penalties requires a clause, a binding deadline, a count of the days attributable to the contractor and, unless the contract provides otherwise, a formal notice (mise en demeure). The decision lies with the client, on the lead consultant’s recommendation. It is notified with its calculation and its reasons.
- Reread the clause. Rate, basis of calculation, cap, milestones concerned, calendar or working days, formalities.
- Settle the binding deadline. The contract period, plus any extensions granted by amendment or by site instruction.
- Count the days of delay between the deadline so established and the actual completion date of the milestone.
- Deduct the periods not attributable to the contractor: late decisions, missing drawings, delay by another trade package, an event recognised by the contract.
- Serve formal notice, unless the contract provides that the deadline passing is enough on its own.
- Notify the calculation and invite comments from the contractor.
- Deduct the sum from an interim valuation or from the final account (DGD, décompte général définitif), as the contract provides.
Under French law, contractual penalties are a fixed sum, agreed in advance, compensating for a breach. The judge may, even without being asked, reduce or increase them when they are manifestly excessive or derisory, and reduce them in the event of partial performance, in proportion to the benefit that performance brought the party owed it (Article 1231-5 of the Civil Code).
Unless non-performance is permanent, the penalty is only incurred once the party in breach has been given formal notice (Article 1231-5, last paragraph). The contract may provide that the obligation simply falling due counts as formal notice (Article 1344 of the Civil Code); these terms must be examined before the sanction is calculated or notified.
The lead consultant records, raises the alarm and may propose a calculation within the scope of its appointment. The decision lies with the client, subject to any powers validly delegated. The file keeps the contractor’s comments and the reasons why certain periods are counted or set aside. On checking the sums due at each interim valuation, see our guide on the payment certificate.
Retention (retenue de garantie) serves a different purpose. Under French law it is capped at 5% of interim payments and secures completion of the work needed to clear the snags recorded at practical completion (Article 1 of Law No. 71-584 of 16 July 1971). It must not be confused with delay penalties.
In short: a penalty stands up if the clause is clear, the deadline proven, the calculation detailed day by day and formal notice served where required. A deduction made without that file opens a second dispute, this time over payment.
What should you do beyond calculating the penalties?
Calculating penalties does not move the site forward. The client first needs a scenario for carrying on: priority tasks, urgent decisions, available resources and financial consequences. It then puts a figure on its actual loss, which the penalty does not always cover, or not on its own.
Any proposed acceleration must be technically feasible and compatible with the expected quality. The financial loss has to be documented: extra costs, deferred income, extended consultants’ appointments or consequences for the operator. Costs avoided are taken into account and double recovery is excluded. Whether a penalty can be combined with other claims depends on the clause and on the losses concerned.
Where no penalty is provided for, compensation may be sought under ordinary French contract law (Article 1231-1 of the Civil Code), on the basis of proven damage and its link with the breach. Unless non-performance is permanent, such damages are only due if the party in breach has first been given formal notice to perform within a reasonable time (Article 1231 of the Civil Code).
When the delay turns into a stoppage, the question is a different one: see our guide stalled site: building a recovery plan.
Delay penalties: the questions clients ask
What is the rate of delay penalties on a private project?
The rate set by your contract. In France, no statute imposes a rate on private works contracts. If the contract refers to the NF P 03-001 standard without departing from it, the Fédération française du bâtiment gives a rate of 1/3,000 of the contract value per day of delay (Article 9.5, October 2017 edition). The CCAP may provide for a different rate.
Is there a legal cap on delay penalties?
Not on private works contracts in France. The cap is the one set by the contract: 5% of the contract value if the NF P 03-001 standard applies, according to the Fédération française du bâtiment, or any other cap written into the CCAP. Without a cap, the judge still has the power to reduce a manifestly excessive penalty.
Is formal notice needed to apply delay penalties?
In principle, yes: unless non-performance is permanent, the penalty is only incurred after formal notice has been served on the contractor. The contract may, however, stipulate that simply passing the date counts as formal notice. Read the clause before doing any calculation: a penalty applied without the required formality is open to challenge.
Can penalties be applied if the contract does not provide for them?
No. Without a clause, there is no fixed penalty. The client can claim damages, but must then prove the delay, its loss and the link between the two, after serving formal notice on the contractor. The burden of proof is heavier and the amount is not known in advance.
Do bad weather and extra works automatically extend the deadline?
No. Their effect depends on what the contract provides and on their actual impact on the tasks that drive the deadline. An extension has to be requested, examined and formalised by amendment or site instruction. You do not deduct a fixed period simply because it rained or because a variation exists.
Can an unsigned schedule be the basis for penalties?
It can help prove the exchanges between the parties and the organisation of the site. Whether it can found a penalty depends on the contract: is the schedule appended to it, was it notified, accepted or disputed? A schedule sent for information does not replace the contractual deadline.
Who calculates delay penalties, and who decides them?
The OPC consultant provides the recorded dates and causes, construction supervision (MOEX) proposes the count of attributable days, and the client decides. The client may also waive all or part of the penalties in an agreement with the contractor, provided the reasons and what is given in return are set down in writing.
How do you organise the evidence before the works end?
Three habits are enough, if they are kept up from the first month: append to the contract a schedule the contractor has accepted, circulate written site minutes after each meeting, and examine each request for an extension when it is made. The delay file then exists before any dispute.
Tracking events regularly makes decisions easier to follow and allows action while the schedule can still be influenced. PRIMOE works in Paris and Île-de-France to analyse slippage, keep the scheduling records and prepare a scenario for carrying on that is shared with all the parties. See our Delivery path and the guide scheduling and coordination (OPC): cost and value.




